Are they just comments?

Fred Wilson writes

The next day I was talking to the founder of a popular blogging service about comments. He pointed out that many comment threads are filled with garbage like LOL, ‘your an idiot’, or worse

He pointed to the comments here at avc and noted how good they were. He called them ‘discussions’.

At Disqus, we call a post a “comment.” Full blown discussion threads are reduced to “responses.” Truthfully, I never liked these labels, but that’s what is familiar to most on the web.

I come from a history of reading and participating on forums and message boards. These messages and posts were not comments — they were full conversations. To a degree, I think referring to comments as such is almost a self-fulfilling label. The comments become superficial, trite responses. Many blogs today have real discussions, where the original blog post or news article is only one of many participants. These conversations should be able to thrive on their own, and not just sit chained to isolated websites.

Perhaps this is why not enough people comment on blogs. I think many are hesitant to participate because the contribution is likely arbitrarily floating and eventually lost. Thoughts should be attributed to the thinkers. They should feel that the discussion has a life beyond the original context. Then, I believe, we’ll see good and more frequent comments. I mean discussions.

This is the direction media is moving in.

View Comments

Daniel on March 1st 2008 in disqus

  • wallace530
    great post sir..
    thanks for sharing. really helped a lot here.
    --------------------------------------------------
    Ugg Boots | Uggs
  • Yes you are right. But I also feel that people get more good at just ignoring the spammy stuff and contunue the talk anyway.
  • Comments I by far superior
  • To me, its an avenue for readers to register their views, thoughts, feelings, experiences or their says, be it good or bad. Readers just have to exercise some responsibilities in whatever they write. I guess I am just having my say here. Bad usage of words or expressions is a no-no. Keep it simple and legible.
  • To me, its an avenue for readers to register their views, thoughts, feelings, experiences or their says, be it good or bad. Readers just have to exercise some responsibilities in whatever they write. I guess I am just having my say here. Bad usage of words or expressions is a no-no. Keep it simple and legible.
  • Good topics will generally get a lot of feedback and interaction. However, good topic is very subjective. News to you may not be news to others, right?
  • True . I think the word ''discussion'' is a more suitable label. Comments allows people to interact, give their opinions and ideas. Thank for sharing !
  • True . I think the word ''discussion'' is a more suitable label. Comments allows people to interact, give their opinions and ideas. Thank for sharing !
  • True . I think the word ''discussion'' is a more suitable label. Comments allows people to interact, give their opinions and ideas. Thank for sharing !
  • If the article does not value-add my thoughts, i wouldn't spend the extra time debating in a comment.
  • If the article does not value-add my thoughts, i wouldn't spend the extra time debating in a comment.
  • absolutely :)
  • absolutely :)
  • absolutely :)
blog comments powered by Disqus